Ohio nursing homes with the CMS High Performing Facility icon: the current list

87 of Ohio’s 922 Medicare-certified nursing homes carry the CMS High Performing Facility icon on Nursing Home Care Compare as of CMS’s October 2026 list. That’s 9.4% of the state, below the national share of 11.6%.

Here’s the full list by county, what the icon records, and what to do if you run one of these buildings or compete with one.

What the icon means

CMS places a trophy on a facility’s Care Compare profile when it qualifies for the Risk-Based Survey, a shorter inspection reserved for buildings with a clean record. Qualifying takes 11 checks at once: a 5-star overall rating, at least 3 stars for staffing, no harm-level citations in the last cycle, an inspection within 18 months, clean staffing and assessment data audits, no staffing waivers, no recent change of ownership, and more.

The list rebuilds every quarter, and the icon stays “until the facility is no longer eligible.” The full explainer covers what that means in practice.

The Ohio list

Hamilton County

• Bayley Place, Cincinnati · 110 beds
• Beechwood Home for Incurables, Cincinnati · 80 beds
• Deupree Cottages, Cincinnati · 24 beds
• Harrison Trail Health Campus, Harrison · 54 beds
• Marjorie P Lee Retirement Community, Cincinnati · 88 beds
• Ohio Living Llanfair, Cincinnati · 36 beds
• Residence at Salem Woods, Cincinnati · 99 beds
• Twin Lakes, Cincinnati · 43 beds

Clermont County

• Atlantes the, Cincinnati · 30 beds
• Eastgate Health Care Center, Cincinnati · 175 beds
• Glen the, Cincinnati · 54 beds
• S.E.M. Haven Health Care Center, Milford · 93 beds
• Siena Gardens Rehabilitation & Transitional Care, Cincinnati · 99 beds

Franklin County

• Mohun Health Care Center, Columbus · 72 beds
• Robert A Barnes Center, Reynoldsburg · 25 beds
• Trueman Pointe Care Center, Hilliard · 72 beds
• Wesley Glen Health Services Corp, Columbus · 56 beds
• Westerwood Rehabilitation, Columbus · 75 beds

Mahoning County

• Austintown Healthcare Center, Youngstown · 89 beds
• Briarfield Place, Boardman · 58 beds
• Caprice Health Care Center, North Lima · 75 beds
• Heritage Manor Jewish Hm for, Youngstown · 72 beds
• Shepherd of the Valley Poland, Poland · 32 beds

Butler County

• Birchwood Care Center, Hamilton · 75 beds
• Glen Meadows, Hamilton · 85 beds
• Golden Years Nursing Center, Hamilton · 70 beds
• Westover Retirement Community, Hamilton · 53 beds

Delaware County

• Capri Gardens, Lewis Center · 82 beds
• Cherith Care Center at Willow Brook, Delaware · 34 beds
• Country View of Sunbury, Sunbury · 99 beds
• Ohio Living Sarah Moore, Delaware · 47 beds

Lorain County

• Avon Oaks Nursing Home, Avon · 99 beds
• Kingston Health Center of Vermilion, Vermilion · 120 beds
• Life Care Center of Elyria, Elyria · 99 beds
• St Mary of the Woods, Avon · 50 beds

Montgomery County

• Bethany Village, Dayton · 227 beds
• Brookhaven Nursing & Rehabilitation Center, Brookville · 99 beds
• Vienna Springs Health Campus, Dayton · 54 beds

Allen County

• Springs of Lima the, Lima · 56 beds
• Vancrest of Delphos, Delphos · 99 beds

Clark County

• Dayspring of Miami Valley Hlth Care Center & Rehab, Fairborn · 133 beds
• Wooded Glen, Springfield · 54 beds

Cuyahoga County

• North Park Care Center, Brook Park · 34 beds
• Westpark Healthcare Campus, Cleveland · 99 beds

Erie County

• Mill Manor Care Center, Vermilion · 33 beds
• Parkvue Health Care Center, Sandusky · 84 beds

Huron County

• Laurels of New London the, New London · 50 beds
• Willows at Willard the, Willard · 69 beds

Licking County

• Johnstown Pointe Nursing & Rehabilitation Center, Johnstown · 117 beds
• Otterbein at Granville, Granville · 22 beds

Lucas County

• Lakes of Monclova Health Campus the, Maumee · 60 beds
• Lakes of Sylvania, the, Sylvania · 62 beds

Ottawa County

• Genoa Retirement Village, Genoa · 68 beds
• Otterbein North Shore, Lakeside · 20 beds

Portage County

• Altercare Post-Acute Rehab Center, Kent · 79 beds
• Tamarack Ridge Health and Rehabilitation, Kent · 96 beds

Trumbull County

• Addison Healthcare Center, Masury · 55 beds
• Otterbein Cortland, Cortland · 39 beds

Tuscarawas County

• Hennis Care Centre of Bolivar, Bolivar · 115 beds
• Park Village Hc Np LLC, New Philadelphia · 40 beds

Wayne County

• Country Pointe, Wooster · 42 beds
• Wooster Community Hospital SNF, Wooster · 22 beds

Adams County

• Eagle Creek Nursing Center, West Union · 85 beds

Ashtabula County

• Pine Grove Healthcare Center, Geneva · 67 beds

Auglaize County

• Vancrest of St Mary’s, St Marys · 66 beds

Brown County

• Ohio Veterans Home - Georgetown, Georgetown · 168 beds

Carroll County

• Carroll Healthcare Center Inc, Carrollton · 52 beds

Columbiana County

• Orchards of East Liverpool, the, East Liverpool · 50 beds

Defiance County

• Vancrest of Hicksville, Hicksville · 61 beds

Fulton County

• Fulton Manor Nursing & Rehab C, Wauseon · 71 beds

Gallia County

• Abbyshire Place Health and Rehabilitation Center L, Bidwell · 95 beds

Geauga County

• Burton Health Care Center, Burton · 90 beds

Hancock County

• The Manor at Greendale, Findlay · 77 beds

Holmes County

• Oak Pointe Nursing & Rehabilitation, Baltic · 85 beds

Jefferson County

• Villa Vista Royale LLC, Steubenville · 54 beds

Logan County

• Indian Lake Rehabilitation Center, Lakeview · 40 beds

Medina County

• Western Reserve Masonic Comm, Medina · 50 beds

Monroe County

• Arbors at Woodsfield, Woodsfield · 85 beds

Paulding County

• Vancrest of Payne, Payne · 40 beds

Pickaway County

• Logan Elm Health Care Center, Circleville · 99 beds

Pike County

• National Church Residences Bristol Village, Waverly · 40 beds

Ross County

• Embassy of Valley View, Frankfort · 50 beds

Sandusky County

• Willows at Bellevue, Bellevue · 60 beds

Shelby County

• Ohio Living Dorothy Love, Sidney · 44 beds

Summit County

• Regency Care of Copley, Akron · 70 beds

Warren County

• Otterbein Lebanon Retirement Community, Lebanon · 154 beds

Wood County

• Willows at Bowling Green the, Bowling Green · 50 beds

Where they cluster

The largest groups sit in Hamilton (8), Clermont (5), Franklin (5). 45 of Ohio’s counties have at least one qualifying building.

If your building is on the list

You have roughly a quarter before the next rebuild to turn the icon into inquiries, tours, and referral conversations. The 7-surface rollout covers the website, Google Business Profile, per-facility social, the lobby, admissions, hospital partners, and current families, with one dated sentence that stays accurate everywhere. The hospital referral piece is the surface with the highest return.

Write the removal plan before the first post. The icon is a status, and statuses end.

MOZART&CO. runs this as a coordinated recognition campaign for every qualifying building in a network, in one week, tracked in the Marketing Hub so the next quarter triggers an update instead of a scramble. We work with operators across Ohio.

If it isn’t

About 88.4% of nursing homes nationally are in the same position, and many of them are strong buildings that missed on a technicality: the survey clock, an acquisition, a staffing star. Find out which of the 11 checks you missed. Three of them respond to work you control this quarter.

About this list

Source: the High Performing Icon column of the CMS Provider Information dataset (NH_ProviderInfo_Sep2026_3.csv) on the Provider Data Catalog, retrieved 2026-10-19. Facility names, cities, counties, and bed counts from the CMS Provider Information dataset as of 2026-10-19. CMS notes that the lists sent to state survey agencies and the icons shown on Care Compare will not always match because of data transmission and posting delays; for any single facility, the Care Compare profile is the reference. This page updates when CMS rebuilds the list.

Running a Ohio building that made the list? Inquire.